Joy Supply makes thin, crisp cookies in Brooklyn, built around a 1908 family recipe from Great Grandpa Oscar’s bakery in Monmouth, Illinois. Founder Lindsay Leopold draws on a decade in food media and product development to pair that old-school oat cookie with carefully sourced ingredients, including oats from a fifth-generation South Dakota farm and crops from regenerative fields. Launched in 2024, the brand calls its approach “farm-born, city-baked.”
Regenerative Organic Certified®
certification
Fair Trade Certified
certification
Otterbein's CookiesSince 1881, Otterbein’s Cookies has baked Maryland’s signature thin-and-crispy cookies, using the same original recipe and method that made the brand a regional staple. The family’s six-ingredient sugar cookie and unmistakable paper-thin crunch remain central to a Maryland tradition now more than 140 years old.WINDSOR MILL, MD
The Good Batch BakeryChef Anna Gordon’s cookie business, launched at the Brooklyn Flea in 2010, grew into The Good Batch’s Clinton Hill flagship in 2014. Gordon and her husband, Steven Hartong, run the bakery as a neighborhood fixture that supplies fresh baked goods to its Brooklyn customers and retailers across New York City, including its signature cookies.BROOKLYN, NY
Otterbein's CookiesSince 1881, Otterbein’s Cookies has baked thin, crispy cookies in Maryland, preserving the signature crunch that began with the Otterbein family’s original recipe. The company still uses that same style of bake and, for its sugar cookies, a deliberately simple six-ingredient formula that has made Otterbein’s a Baltimore-area staple for generations.WINDSOR MILL, MD
The Famous 4th Street Cookie CompanyFor more than 40 years, The Famous 4th Street Cookie Company has baked Philadelphia’s hometown cookies from a treasured family recipe, including its signature big, thick chocolate chip cookie. Rooted in the former 4th and Bainbridge Streets location and now baking at its East Falls bakery, the company uses all-natural ingredients without preservatives or artificial flavors. Cookies are baked and shipped the same day so they arrive soft and homemade-tasting.PHILADELPHIA, PA